Reynolds Kitchen 70485125390 – Product Liability Lawyer

2026-02-19 – A consumer has reported severe burn injuries after a Reynolds Kitchens® Heavy Duty Medium Roasting Pan collapsed during normal oven use, according to a hazard report filed with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) SaferProducts.gov database. The incident, classified as a burn hazard involving a design defect, resulted in the consumer receiving emergency department treatment. The product is manufactured by Reynolds Consumer Products.

Product Details

Brand Name: Reynolds Kitchen 70485125390
Manufacturer: Reynolds Consumer Products
Retailer: Walmart
Incident Report Number: 5867871
Severity Type Name: Emergency Department Treatment Received
Severity Type ID: 9

Incident Overview

On November 24, 2023, a consumer was using a Reynolds Kitchens® Heavy Duty Medium Roasting Pan to bake a lasagna. According to the incident report filed with the CPSC, the consumer placed the disposable aluminum pan on a non-disposable cookie sheet before putting it in the oven, following the manufacturer's instructions. When removing the lasagna from the oven, the consumer lifted the pan while it was fully supported by the cookie sheet underneath. Despite this, the roasting pan structurally collapsed, causing hot contents to spill onto the consumer's hand and arm, resulting in significant burns that required emergency department treatment.

The consumer later submitted a follow-up report to the CPSC, noting that the manufacturer had responded by claiming the product was not used in accordance with instructions, specifically that it was not lifted and supported with a non-disposable cookie sheet. The consumer disputes this, stating that the pan was used exactly as directed on the packaging, including the warning to "Lift and support pan with a non-disposable cookie sheet." The consumer argues that if a "heavy duty" pan collapses while properly supported, the warning may not adequately mitigate the risk, and other consumers could face similar hazards.

Safety Concerns

Immediate Dangers: When a roasting pan collapses during removal from an oven, hot food and liquids can spill onto the user's skin, causing severe burns. The structural failure of the pan eliminates the barrier between the user and scalding contents, leading to rapid injury that may require emergency medical treatment.

Long-Term Risks: Burn injuries from hot food spills can result in permanent scarring, nerve damage, and reduced mobility in affected limbs. Repeated thermal trauma may also increase the risk of skin infections and long-term sensitivity issues.

Who Might Be Affected: The primary person at risk is the individual handling the pan, typically the cook. However, bystanders—including children or others nearby—could also be splashed if the pan fails suddenly. In commercial or family settings, multiple people may be exposed.

Environmental Triggers: The failure risk is heightened when the pan is used with heavy, dense foods (e.g., lasagna, casseroles) that place significant weight on the pan's base. High oven temperatures may also weaken the aluminum structure over time, making it more prone to collapse when lifted, even with proper support.

What Our Clients Say

What Consumers Should Do

Stop Using Immediately: If you own a Reynolds Kitchens® Heavy Duty Medium Roasting Pan (model 70485125390), discontinue use until the manufacturer's safety can be confirmed. Even if you have not experienced a failure, the pan may pose a risk of collapse.

Preserve the Product: Keep the pan in its current condition, along with any packaging or instructions. Do not discard or alter the product, as it may serve as evidence if you later seek compensation for injuries or property damage.

Document the Incident: Take photographs of the pan, the area where the spill occurred, and any injuries. Write down the date, time, and sequence of events. Save receipts, medical bills, and any correspondence with the manufacturer or retailer.

Seek Medical Attention: If you or someone else sustains burns from a collapsing pan, seek immediate medical evaluation. Burn injuries can be more severe than they initially appear, and prompt treatment reduces the risk of complications.

Contact the Manufacturer: Report the incident to Reynolds Consumer Products directly. Provide details about the product, the failure, and any injuries. Request a written acknowledgment of your report.

Report to the CPSC: File a report with the CPSC at SaferProducts.gov to help alert other consumers and potentially trigger a recall. Reference incident report number 5867871 if applicable.

Check for Recalls: Visit CPSC.gov to check whether this product or similar models have been recalled. Even without a recall, consumers should remain vigilant.

If you or a loved one suffered injury or property damage from this product, consider speaking with a product liability attorney to understand your legal options.

Manufacturer's Response

Reynolds Consumer Products responded to the incident report, stating that the product was not used in accordance with instructions because the baking pan was not lifted and supported with a non-disposable cookie sheet. The company maintains that when used as directed, it has not identified a defect or an unreasonable risk of injury. It encourages consumers to follow all package instructions and warnings to reduce the risk of injury.

Legal Help Available

H Law Group is a California product liability law firm dedicated to holding manufacturers accountable for unsafe products. We represent clients on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Our team offers free, no-obligation consultations to discuss your case and explore your options. If you or a loved one was injured by Reynolds Kitchen 70485125390 or a similar product, contact H Law Group at (888) 499-4948 for a free, no-obligation consultation.